The tale of these battles constitutes a trilogy, illustrating the unquestionable heroism that will never accept defeat and the inexhaustible vanity that will never admit a mistake. We have biggest database of and. The day before the battle, Haig wrote in his diary that 'the men were in splendid spirits', for he had told them that the barbed-wire had been cut successfully, and that the German trenches had been reduced to nothing more than rubble and mud. They're the fellows who are saving the world, and they're getting killed every day. He acted on this view, and, at the last, he was right, though it is open to argument not only that victory could have been won sooner elsewhere but that Haig's method of winning it was clumsy, tragically expensive of life, and based for too long on a misreading of the facts. The British decided they had the relieve the pressure on the French.
He was created an earl for his leadership in 1919. He was called 'The Butcher of the Somme'. Germany, his opponent, had been winning land, continental wars since Napoleon, and had worked out a far better system of land warfare, especially in the defense. He had a very good tactic and without it the war would have gone nowhere. Telescope observation from our own lines would again only give a limited view, and no sense of depth for the entanglements.
One sees so many of these cemeteries and so many stones—along with the vast memorial at Thievpal bearing the names of some 70,000 British soldiers whose bodies were never recovered—that after a few hours of it, you feel numb. This did not go to plan and were almost useless, as the German trenches were too well defended, and very deep as they were defending, stationary, so had more time to dig the trenches. He opposed the idea of counter-battery fire using your own artillery to take out the enemy's field guns and is widely condemned for repeating failed tactics over and over again in the belief that it was the troops, not the methods, that had failed. Here is an extended excerpt to provide context. We are, naturally, not intrigued by unsuccessful generals any more than we like to read about ballplayers who hit.
Douglas MacArthur In war there is no substitute for victory. The battle commenced in 1916, half way through the First World War. You can help Wikiquote by. This source is also reliable because it was written in December 1916, right after the war ended. The Prime Minister David Lloyd George despised him and saw to it after the war that he never held another active post. And it gives out information about Haig and his team.
The frightful casualties appalled me. Personally, I know nothing of Lord Haig. General Military History of all ages the quote of haig and the wire and artillery taken quiet literally is probably true if he did say this as quoted. Arm, I wasnt disagreeing with yr first para but yr second. The same remark of Haig's is alluded to by Montgomery in his 'A Concise History of Warfare' but alas neither he nor Liddell-Hart mention the original circumstances in which Haig made the remark, or when 1914-1915? Douglas MacArthur Haig shouldn't be blamed for the Somme because a lot of the reasons were from the war conditions when the soldiers having to carry a load of equipment to try and keep themselves safe and kill the Germans that was causing the soldiers to move really slow.
He had little general intelligence, no imagination. Critics of Haig are remorseless on this point—the man was so confident in his outdated ideas that he never allowed actual battlefield experience to challenge them. In truth neither Haig or Rawlinson had any idea what the shelling had achieved or not as the case may be. Air observation was probably the most precise but meant coming down low to get a good view and running the gauntlet of Archie. His pleasures lean toward the athletic and social. Another factor was that of those 1M shells, it has been claimed that a large number, possibly up to a third failed to detonate.
Consequently, he has developed a skill in both. Field Marshall Douglas Haig is most associated with the Battle of the Somme in World War One. He tried his best and put a lot of effort on the planning and war, so that Britain had its victory at last. Douglas MacArthur Build me a son, O Lord, who will be strong enough to know when he is weak, and brave enough to face himself when he is afraid, one who will be proud and unbending in honest defeat, and humble and gentle in victory. He had no idea what a real war is.
Tunnelling under the enemy wire on a large scale would have got over the need for the destruction of the forward defences by a bombardment which made the ground impassable. He said he knew what they wanted. They were stuck with him. They're a very powerful country. Each email contains an unsubscribe link. In my book I argue that Haig's role in the transformation of the British army from the clumsy amateur force of 1916 to a superb instrument of war in 1918 was his greatest achievement. There followed, in December 1899, a month of disasters for nearly all British units.
He was afraid of newspaper men - afraid of any men but those he gathered round him, and they were mostly like himself. So although I did try to sing properly it obviously has hilarious results when you can't sing. Andrew Jackson had demonstrated the flaw in this method of attack during the War of 1812, and the American Civil War had truly driven the point home on a dozen different occasions. Haig's one-step breakthrough attempt was the antithesis of Robertson's cautious approach of exhausting the enemy with artillery and limited advances. However, Haig continued to use them even though he knew they usually would not work and would just be a waste of money, shells and soldiers. As well as all this, Haig was fighting for the allied to he was the attackers, which means that they had to be the ones to stand up and walk across no mans land while the Germans sit on machine guns slaughtering our soldiers. He mentioned the ballad during his final address to the Corps of Cadets on his final departure from the Army I believe somewhere around 1962.