Is breaking the law ever justified. Breaking The Law Can Be Justified Free Essays 2019-03-05

Is breaking the law ever justified Rating: 4,5/10 809 reviews

In your own opinion, could breaking the law ever be justified?

is breaking the law ever justified

But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security. These are two people that would be considered morally just. In such cases, civil disobedience might be necessary. By breaking the law, protesters put at risk our constitutional right to gather peaceably assemble , debate, criticize our government and otherwise freely shape the discourse and evolution of our representative democracy. I believe that if failing to break a law would put someone's life in danger then that law should be broken. Choosing to overthrow the government such as Jefferson and the continental congress did or choosing to change racial segregation as King did are two events in which individuals took a stand and broke the law to better human life.

Next

Conscience and The Rule of Law: Is Breaking The Law Ever Justified?

is breaking the law ever justified

Studies done on game theory show that special interest groups will almost always come out the winners in the competition over government policies because for an investment of x amount of resources they can make a return of many hundreds of times their initial investment. Those who fall outside of this category would therefore believe that we are not bound over to obey the law and that in fact we should be morally obliged to disobey any law that we consider to be immoral. When they burn a car dealership to protest gas guzzling cars, they did not just hurt the car dealer, but its employees, those who were getting cars fixed there that are not scorched, and money out of the business that goes to repairing the damage instead of buying and investing and growing. Population and economic growth, oil and gas exports and our love of light trucks have been among the key drivers of our rising emissions. But breaking the law is more or less unavoidable, if for census reasons only. It is not moral for the law to tell someone what not to wear; it is taking the freedom of choice away. When the voters decide who to vote for they have to consider the the stand of each candidate on many different issues, and their chances of winning.

Next

Is breaking the law ever justifiable?

is breaking the law ever justified

There is however a problem with this situation, in so much as it relies on appealing to a set moral code to justify our actions and such a moral code is merely an abstracted system of laws. Why I am saying like this? You're Accused Of A Crime You Didn't Commit Although people are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law, in practice it is very common for a person's rights and liberties to be deprived prior to this. Decision making, Decision making software, Decision theory 2156 Words 6 Pages A social structure is mandatory for the survival of humans. This established a happier independent India. Yet the police are still to be civil, they are never to be beaten, no one is to burn their cars in like minded protest, and they should receive full legal representation if they are unable to afford it. These are to live, breed, and to dominate. And for those of you it does apply to, sir, I can hardly offer any advice you don't already know, you having stabbed so many corrupt parking bylaw enforcement officers on the decks of decommissioned battleships over the years.

Next

Breaking The Law Can Be Justified Free Essays

is breaking the law ever justified

And more importantly, if we break it, is it ever right? For the development of a place and to move ahead, sometimes it is the rules that are preventing us from doing so. Ethical egoism Under ethical egoism, Tom should tell Michael what Brenda is doing, as he is feeling worried and guilty and this would ease his mind. How does one determine when a law is just or unjust? Civil disobedience was practised to great effect by people such as Ghandi and Martin Luther King. Even if there is such a duty, then, unlawful strikes, whistle-blowing and other acts of disobedience might be justified. Anything can be settled in a fair way. If they are sworn to uphold the Constitution, and they enforce laws which violate the rights of the people, does that make them criminals as well? Such acts landed him in jail and also put him and many of his.

Next

Is breaking the law ever justifiable?

is breaking the law ever justified

Many would argue that the killing of another individual is by far one of the worse crimes that can be committed. It is just a way showing the love of nature to many and there is no reason why it is wrong to do so. Some people argue that war is always justifiable while others argue that it can never be. Hence, breaking laws can be justified if that brings a large benefit to a large group of people. That sense of urgency is why a growing number of scientists are advocating non-violent civil disobedience to shake up governments, industry and media. Even though laws are meant to maintain order and protect rights, it is not always justified; some might be unfair to minorities whereas others might stir up a revolution.

Next

Can Breaking the Law Ever Be Justified? Essay

is breaking the law ever justified

The teacher got in and I acted as if I was waking up my roommate. Heck, in some cases, like if maybe your town has unusually draconian parking restrictions, parking illegally might even be the noble thing to do. Many people view terrorism the same way as Ben Achour, especially in America. There are so many laws that are created for one purpose and actually end up being a bad law that protects the criminal instead of the protecting the citizens. Consequentialism, Ethics, Immanuel Kant 826 Words 3 Pages Chapter 1 Risk Management and Sources of Law Risk Management Risk Management — is the process of identifying, evaluating and responding to the possibility of harmful events.

Next

In your own opinion, could breaking the law ever be justified?

is breaking the law ever justified

Cindy Sheehan is a good example of how hard it is today in our country to break the law and make reform. Jefferson authored one of the most important documents in American history. After killing many Spaniards, the African slaves were then captured and put on trial. In my experience, pushing over a parking bylaw enforcement officer -- even a corrupt one -- usually doesn't qualify in the eyes of most observers. Marches are a waste of time; witness the hundreds of thousands who marched fruitlessly against the war in Iraq. At the same time the Bible lauds persons who were not submissive.

Next

FREE When is someone justified in breaking the law? Essay

is breaking the law ever justified

We'll except cases like North Korea's leadership that sends thousands to starve in Gulags today. On no moral grounds can such a law that violates every basic right and freedom to which all humans are entitle can ever be justified. You may not agree with that, but the facts prove that the primary job of our government is to protect our rights; everything else was secondary. Law based on truth in itself cannot be broken, only violated. The member-supported Council of Canadians has engaged in all sorts of civil disobedience, including sandbagging towns and provincial legislatures to point out how rising sea levels would affect them. Most activists who perform civil disobedience are scrupulously non-violent, and willingly accept legal penalties.

Next